Can i sacrifice an attacking creature

It sounds like the Goblin in question was given a blocker during the Declare Blockers step. At that point, the other player does have the opportunity use an ability to sacrifice the goblin, and if the goblin is doomed to die, that's probably a good choice. However, once combat damage happens, that sacrificed goblin won't be around anymore. You say this:. It will have counted as attacking , but since it's dead by the combat damage step, it's gone and won't actually be there to do anything.

Your blocker won't take damage from the goblin, for instance - the goblin will be dead and gone. There was a time in the past when you could cast spells and use abilities during combat damage, so that the goblin could deal combat damage and get sacrificed too, but that was weird and got removed from the rules a few years ago in M Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group.

Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more. Can you sacrifice a creature that's in the middle of an attack? Ask Question. Asked 7 years, 4 months ago. Active 3 years, 9 months ago. Viewed 20k times. Improve this question. Could you name the cards being used here? That would let us more concretely discuss the situation. Namely, the card that let your opponent place goblins, and the card used to sacrifice one. The other way this can go is: You cast Phantasmal Image.

By asking a question about choices not normally made until resolution, that player is assumed to be allowing the spell to resolve. Does it resolve? If my opponent taps his creature for something, can I respond by tapping it first? Will it stop the ability if I kill the creature in response?

When a player has priority and announces a spell or ability, they get to choose targets, if any, and pay the costs before the opponent can respond. By the time you get that opportunity, all the costs have been paid.

That spell or ability is already on the stack, and will resolve unless you do something to specifically counter it. What happens if there are multiple triggers at the same time? What order do they happen? First, you put your 2 triggers on the stack in whatever order you want. Then, the opponent does the same. You and your opponent each have a Mimic Vat , and a creature dies.

Do blocking creatures tap? Can I tap a creature to activate an ability after blocking and have it still deal damage? Creatures only become tapped when paying costs that require you to tap them, when an effect instructs you to tap them e. As soon as blocks are declared, those blocks are locked in.

Nothing will cause a blocked creature to be unblocked except a couple quirky cards that say so explicitly. Other Versions. Blessed Alliance 2 Instant Escalate Pay this cost for each mode chosen beyond the first. Celestial Flare 2 Instant Target player sacrifices an attacking or blocking creature.

Dispense Justice 3 Instant Target player sacrifices an attacking creature. Entrapment Maneuver 4 Instant Target player sacrifices an attacking creature. Flooded Woodlands 4 Enchantment Green creatures can't attack unless their controller sacrifices a land for each green creature they control that's attacking. Heroism 3 Enchantment Sacrifice a white creature: For each attacking red creature, prevent all combat damage that would be dealt by that creature this turn unless its controller pays.

Marjhan can't attack unless defending player controls an Island. When you control no Islands, sacrifice Marjhan. Reclamation 4 Enchantment Black creatures can't attack unless their controller sacrifices a land for each black creature they control that's attacking. Sacrifice Play 3 Instant A person outside the game chooses an attacking or blocking creature target opponent controls. Soul Snare 1 Enchantment , Sacrifice Soul Snare: Exile target creature that's attacking you or a planeswalker you control.

Wing Shards 3 Instant Target player sacrifices an attacking creature. All Rights Reserved. Gatherer works better in the Companion app!